Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
I like this idea a lot. Fuck it. It'll get rid of the stagnation. For better or worse we'll have a set path to the future rather than convoluted mediocrity.
Might find a way to make the WD selection independent so someone is holding the others somewhat accountable and is at least a little independent.
Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
Sounds interesting. It's definitely worth seeing how it'd work in practice. I'd be up for using it after this war.
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Dark Remalf
I like it, the question is, will WC vote it out?
Eh, actually, he brings up a very valid point. Don't think it'd work out, so we shouldn't rock the vote boat. Instead, we can vote on our favorite dead memes and have them as FMs. That'd work out much better IMO.
Such as "The Line" and "Total Ties for MVP" as the FMs. Would be a glorious war.
It's 3 am and I have no idea what my mind was thinking when I wrote the above.
Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
This couldn't be worse than the current system. I'm all for trying it.
I would like to nominate W3z4b1 and Mos Deaf for the FM team.
Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
Only real way to see it work, is to try it out. At the end of its trial run, the community can then decide what they prefer.
Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
This is a interesting idea, it may make WC more efficient but not as effective.
My main concern is if we have two people with the same views, we may not give us the best solutions for situations.
For example george lucas, in the original trilogy he had people with different opinions and views as him and because of that we had a classic trilogy. fastforward to the prequels and he has a bunch of yes men and well you know what happend next.
All im saying is a wider range of perspective is good when deciding what is best for the community.
Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
Quote:
Originally Posted by
UnfoldedFreedom
This is a interesting idea, it may make WC more efficient but not as effective.
My main concern is if we have two people with the same views, we may not give us the best solutions for situations.
For example george lucas, in the original trilogy he had people with different opinions and views as him and because of that we had a classic trilogy. fastforward to the prequels and he has a bunch of yes men and well you know what happend next.
All im saying is a wider range of perspective is good when deciding what is best for the community.
advisement can be handled by high com and officers, and War directors are still a thing.
Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
why not have an FM run with their Gen much like a President and VP? Allows for more transparency and will let people choose who will take over in the case of an FMs absence
Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
The idea is to remove conflicts between the two armies, or at least, lessen them. Running as FM/general would probably INCREASE tensions, as both sides will be further locked into their respective sides, seeing the other side as the enemy, etc.
Re: Suggestion: Team Field Marshall elections
So instead of hating one imcompetent FM, We can hate two? oh yes im all about this