Commentary; Yay or Nay?

[bl4yze]

We got mixed reactions to last week's Top 5. Would you guys be opposed to commentary if it was more thorough (In the sense that it'd essentially be quiet music with someone commentating each play, in light of MLG's Top 10s with Puckett), or would you prefer just a montage style syncing-to-the-music with some nifty effects going on?

[KillerGUNNY132]

I personally prefer them with just music.

[Houdini]

Just music. Which poll option is for just music?

[bl4yze]

Just music. Which poll option is for just music?

Good call, didn't realize how the poll questions and the forum post didn't really correlate. Nay is for no commentary. Will edit now.

[VerbotenDonkey]

I personally prefer them with just music.

[xxXENOPIRATExx]

I personally prefer them with just music.

i just watch with the sound off anyway.

[Guzzie]

If the commentary is done it has to be done well, if not, then it should not be done at all. Why not try it one more time, see how it goes, and take it from there. I just don't like the way the previous one was done.

[bazongaman502]

If you are going to do commentary, have it like how Anoj does his top 10's. Not random talking or talking through the whole thing. The music sounds more professional than commentary.

[Lol its James]

If you are going to do commentary, have it like how Anoj does his top 10's. Not random talking or talking through the whole thing. The music sounds more professional than commentary.

[bl4yze]

If you are going to do commentary, have it like how Anoj does his top 10's. Not random talking or talking through the whole thing. The music sounds more professional than commentary.

I've seen his top 10s before but I'm about to go to sleep at the grand hour of 9am, will reference it when I wake up.